Is Your SEO Working? How to Measure Success with Google Analytics and Search Console (Part 6 of 6)

Written by Brian Bailey
AI Search Optimisation

The final stage of a comprehensive SEO strategy is measurement. Tracking performance is essential for validating efforts, demonstrating return on investment (ROI), and making data-informed decisions. SEO performance should be evaluated based on long-term trends rather than short-term fluctuations.

Core Measurement Platforms

Two platforms provided by Google are fundamental for measuring SEO performance:

  • Google Search Console (GSC): Monitors a site’s performance within Google’s organic search results. It provides data on crawling, indexing, and search visibility, acting as a direct communication channel between your website and Google.
  • Google Analytics (GA4): Tracks and reports on website traffic and user behaviour after they arrive on the site. It provides critical insights into audience engagement and conversions.

Key Metrics in Google Search Console (GSC)

Within the “Performance” report in GSC, the following metrics are central to understanding search visibility:

Impressions
The total number of times any URL from your site appeared in search results viewed by a user. A consistent upward trend in impressions is a primary indicator of growing visibility.
Clicks
The number of times a user clicked through from a search result to your site. This figure represents your actual organic search traffic.
Click-Through Rate (CTR)
The percentage of impressions that resulted in a click (Clicks ÷ Impressions). A low CTR for a high-ranking page may indicate that its title tag and meta description are not compelling enough to attract clicks.
Average Position
The average ranking of your site’s URLs for the queries it appeared for. A decreasing number indicates an improvement in average ranking position over time.

Key Metrics in Google Analytics (GA4)

Key reports and metrics within Google Analytics provide insight into post-click user activity:

Organic Traffic
Located in the “Traffic acquisition” report, filtering by the “Organic Search” channel isolates the volume of traffic generated specifically from SEO efforts.
User Engagement
A high engagement rate indicates that the content on the page aligns well with the user’s search intent. An engaged session is one that lasts longer than 10 seconds, has a conversion event, or has at least two pageviews.
Conversions
This is arguably the most important metric for business objectives. Tracking predefined goals, such as contact form submissions, phone calls, or e-commerce purchases, directly demonstrates the ROI of the SEO strategy.

Utilising Data for Strategy Refinement

These platforms create a feedback loop for continuous improvement. For example, if a page identified in GSC has high impressions but a low CTR, the strategic response is to test a more compelling title tag and meta description. If a page in GA4 shows high organic traffic but low engagement, the content should be reviewed and enhanced to better satisfy user intent.

Conclusion

This series has provided a foundational overview of SEO, covering keyword research, on-page, technical, and off-page strategies, and finally, performance measurement. Effective SEO is an ongoing process of implementation, analysis, and refinement based on reliable data.